Blog Article
THIS IS SCOTT SATTERFIELD’S FINAL CHANCE TO RESURRECT CINCINNATI
Scott Satterfield has 12 Saturdays to save his job.
After back-to-back losing seasons and a dismal 8-16 record, the Cincinnati head coach enters 2025 with the temperature rising and patience wearing thin. The contrast couldn’t be more stark between Satterfield’s tenure and the Luke Fickell era that preceded it—a golden age that saw the Bearcats crash the College Football Playoff and compile a stunning 53-10 record.
For Bearcats fans who once tasted the sweetness of national relevance, the current state of affairs is unacceptable.
The Brutal Truth: Satterfield’s On The Hot Seat
Is Scott Satterfield the right man for the job?
That question hangs over Nippert Stadium like a storm cloud as the Bearcats enter a pivotal 2025 campaign. The statistical reality is sobering:
- Satterfield’s .333 winning percentage stands in stark contrast to the program’s recent history
- Cincinnati finished 2024 with a 5-7 record after a promising 5-2 start
- Five consecutive losses to end last season continued a troubling pattern
- Industry analysts, including On3’s Andy Staples, have placed Satterfield firmly on the hot seat
“We’re trending up, and we’re going in the right direction,” Satterfield claimed after the final game of 2024, pointing to young players gaining experience.
But the math suggests otherwise.

The Financial Stakes Are Enormous
Cincinnati invested heavily in Satterfield when they hired him.
His six-year, $3.4 million annual contract runs through 2028, with a 100% buyout clause for early termination—a potentially expensive decision for Athletic Director John Cunningham if the team struggles again. The financial commitment also includes a record $7.25 million assistant coaching pool, bringing the total coaching investment to $10.65 million annually.
This massive financial stake only heightens the pressure to produce results immediately.
A Coaching Staff Overhaul Was Necessary
Satterfield recognized changes were needed and acted accordingly:
- Special Teams and Cornerbacks Coach Kerry Coombs departed
- Co-Defensive Coordinator and Stars Coach Nate Fuqua left the program
- Adam Braithwaite joined from Samford to coach safeties
- Eddie Hicks arrived from LSU as cornerbacks analyst
- Special teams will see complete restructuring after ranking 80th nationally in net field position
“Tim Connor is still on our staff here… I want all eyes on it,” Satterfield explained about special teams. “We’ve got to put the best guys on the field… We’re going to do all we can to emphasize our special teams and all hands on deck in the coaching staff.”
The staff changes signal Satterfield’s awareness that the status quo was unacceptable.
The Players Who Will Determine Cincinnati’s Fate
Will these key players elevate the program or continue the downward trend?
Offensive Firepower
- Brendan Sorsby (QB): Generated 2,453 passing yards with 16 touchdowns through the air and 8 more on the ground in 2024
- Corey Kiner (RB): Produced back-to-back 1,000-yard seasons, including 1,153 yards in 2024
- Xzavier Henderson (WR): Led the team with 52 receptions for 632 yards in 2024
- Joe Royer (TE): Provides stability and leadership in the passing game
Defensive Anchors
- Dontay Corleone (DL): Returns as the standout defensive lineman and NFL prospect
- Jack Dingle and Jared Bartlett (LB): Veteran linebackers expected to anchor the middle of the defense
- Josh Minkins and Derrick Canteen: Returning secondary leaders
Impact Transfers
- Tawee Walker (RB): Adds power and experience from Wisconsin
- Cyrus Allen (WR): Brings deep-threat capability from Texas A&M
- Matthew McDoom (CB): Bolsters the secondary from Coastal Carolina
- Taran Tyo (OL): Provides offensive line experience from Ball State
- Christian Harrison (DB): Competes for starting role after transferring from Tennessee
The talent is there, but integration and development remain critical questions.
NFL Draft Prospects Creating Their Own Stories
Despite team struggles, several Bearcats are generating NFL Draft buzz:
- Luke Kandra (OG): The All-Big 12 offensive guard has allowed just one sack over 24 games
- Corey Kiner (RB): Consecutive 1,000-yard seasons have scouts taking notice
- John Williams (OT): Consistent starter at left tackle with prototypical size
- Xzavier Henderson (WR): Reliable hands and production make him an intriguing prospect
Individual success stories could help change the program’s perception among recruits.
The Statistical Case For Optimism
Can Cincinnati turn close losses into victories in 2025?
The 2024 statistics reveal reasons for cautious optimism:
- Balanced attack: 236.5 passing yards, 184.1 rushing yards per game
- Efficient ground game: 5.2 yards per carry
- Solid completion percentage: 63.8% team completion rate
- First down advantage: +3.3 first downs per game over opponents
Four one-score losses suggest that fine-tuning, rather than a complete overhaul, could flip the script.
The Roadblocks Standing In Their Way
But significant obstacles remain before Cincinnati can compete for bowl eligibility:
- Turnover margin: -0.3 per game in 2024 proved costly in close games
- Defensive inconsistency: 385.5 total yards allowed per game
- Red zone efficiency: Scoring didn’t match yardage production
- Special teams liability: Among the nation’s worst in field position
- Late-season fades: Back-to-back years with 5+ game losing streaks
These aren’t minor issues—they’re program-defining weaknesses that must be addressed immediately.
A Schedule That Offers Both Opportunity And Peril
The 2025 slate features pivotal matchups that will define Cincinnati’s season:
Must-Win Home Games
- UCF (October 11): This is a winnable rivalry game with Big 12 standing implications
- Baylor (October 25): This is a critical swing game against a rebuilding Bears team
- BYU (November 22): Late-season opportunity against a beatable opponent
- Bowling Green (September 6): This is a non-conference game that cannot slip away
- Northwestern State (September 13): FCS opponent that must be handled decisively
Season-Defining Road Tests
- Nebraska (August 27): The season opener at Arrowhead Stadium sets the tone
- Kansas (September 27): First conference road test against an improving Jayhawks team
- Oklahoma State (October 18): Challenging trip to Stillwater
- Utah (November 1): Perhaps the most challenging game on the schedule
- TCU (November 29): The season finale that could determine bowl eligibility
Early momentum is essential with this challenging schedule.

The Pathway To Salvation For Satterfield
What must happen for Cincinnati to reach bowl eligibility and cool Satterfield’s hot seat?
- Quarterback elevation: Brendan Sorsby must reduce turnovers and increase TD production
- Special teams revival: The restructured coaching approach must yield immediate improvement
- Turnover creation: The defense must generate more than 1.2 takeaways per game
- Transfer impact: Newcomers need to make immediate contributions
- Health preservation: Key players like Kiner and Sorsby must stay injury-free
- Early momentum: At least a 3-1 start is essential before hitting the Big 12 gauntlet
- Home-field advantage: Nippert Stadium must become a true advantage again
The margin for error is nonexistent.

The Bottom Line: It’s Now Or Never For Satterfield
The clock is ticking loudly in Cincinnati.
Industry projections suggest another 5-7 finish, but program expectations demand at least 6-6 and bowl eligibility. With a buyout that becomes increasingly prohibitive the longer Cincinnati waits, 2025 represents an actual inflection point for Satterfield and the program.
As the Bearcats continue spring practice and Nebraska looms on the horizon, the question isn’t whether Satterfield is on the hot seat—it’s whether he can finally deliver the results this proud program demands.
Twelve Saturdays will tell the story.
Become an Insider
Don’t miss another deep dive into college football’s most crucial storylines and program developments. Our team-by-team analysis gives you the insider perspective to understand where each program is headed in 2025 and beyond. Subscribe for free now to access our comprehensive breakdowns, exclusive hot seat rankings, and in-depth conference analysis delivered to your inbox. Join thousands of college football insiders who trust Coaches Hot Seat to keep them ahead of the game. Hit the link below to unlock all our premium content and never miss another update.