Coaches Hot Seat Rankings – Week 12

Winning Won’t Save You. Money Might.

Riley jumps to No. 4, Lupoi crashes the Top 10, and USC learns waiting doesn’t make a buyout cheaper.

Deion Sanders, Sonny Dykes, and Tony Elliott all won this weekend, and none of them moved.

Coaches Hot Seat ranks all 138 FBS head coaches every week by how much pressure they’re under. These are pressure rankings, not firing predictions. With two weeks left in the regular season, most of these jobs come down to one question: who can afford to write the check?

Here are the Week 12 Coaches Hot Seat Rankings.

1. Deion Sanders, Colorado (4-6) | Last week: No. 1
Colorado beat No. 14 Houston 42-32, and Sanders said the field storming felt “like we just won the Super Bowl.” It’s a 4-6 team, and Colorado reportedly can’t afford to fire him.

2. Sonny Dykes, TCU (5-5) | Last week: No. 2
TCU beat a Kansas State team that landed about three hours before kickoff. Two weeks ago, fans chanted “Fire Sonny” during a win, and now TCU needs to beat unbeaten Utah or 9-1 Texas Tech to reach a bowl.

3. Tony Elliott, Virginia (5-5) | Last week: No. 3
Virginia beat Cal 36-7 in front of a season-low 39,423. A year after an ACC title game, the Cavaliers are one win from a bowl, and his extension through 2030 is doing the heavy lifting.

4. Lincoln Riley, USC (7-3) | Last week: No. 11
Indiana won 27-13, and USC’s playoff hopes went with it. By our math, firing him after this season costs at least $63 million, and waiting doesn’t save USC a dime, because every year it waits, it pays him a salary instead.

5. Matt Rhule, Nebraska (6-4) | Last week: No. 5
Nebraska shut out Rutgers 31-0, and the fans still did the buyout math. He’s 0-10 against ranked teams, and The Athletic puts his buyout near $64 million.

6. Kyle Whittingham, Michigan (5-5) | Last week: No. 6
Michigan lost 31-7 at Oregon, and fans at the postgame tent told him to go back to Utah. Utah is 10-0.

7. Luke Fickell, Wisconsin (6-4) | Last week: No. 17
Wisconsin lost 24-21 at a Maryland team that had fired its coach and played without its starting quarterback. An unconfirmed report says Wisconsin has decided to move on.

8. Tosh Lupoi, Cal (3-7) | Last week: No. 20
Down 9-0, Cal ran a fake field goal on 4th-and-goal, and Virginia returned the interception 100 yards. “Obviously, disaster struck,” Lupoi said. Disaster didn’t strike, Coach. You called it.

9. Dabo Swinney, Clemson (6-4) | Last week: No. 7
Clemson lost 20-6 at home to a 2-7 Georgia Tech team, its first loss to a team with a losing record since 2010. CBS reports he’s owed $60 million starting in 2027, so the statue isn’t going anywhere.

10. Joe Moorhead, Akron (1-9) | Last week: No. 8
Akron lost 42-14 to Western Michigan for its eighth straight loss and ran 37 plays to Western Michigan’s 80. He’s 14-44 in his fifth season.

Outside the Top 10

Brent Venables drops 33 spots to No. 37 after Oklahoma’s regents chair said, “There is no hot seat.” Lane Kiffin climbs to No. 59 after Texas beat LSU with three seconds left. UTEP fired Scotty Walden on Nov. 16, three weeks after its AD said, “You just don’t quit on people.”

Want the rest?

The newsletter version has expanded analysis on each coach, our read on which jobs open next, and every coach in the Top 10 in full.

On Friday, newsletter subscribers get the Diagnosis, our weekly deep dive on one coach. This week, it’s Tosh Lupoi, and the problems at Cal go well past the head coach.

Subscribe to Coaches Hot Seat

See all 138 coaches in the Week 12 Coaches Hot Seat Rankings

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

There’s No Ideal College Football Coach. There Are Five.

An Ohio State fan asked the question. The 2026 season answered it, and Columbus won’t love the answer.

Walking out of a football game, an Ohio State fan turned to me with a question.

“What’s the profile of the ideal college football coach today?”

Lousy week to ask it if you bleed scarlet and gray. His team is 6-3 and ranked No. 21.

The honest answer: there isn’t one profile.

It changes by conference, by region, and by school. What works in Athens doesn’t work in Ames. What Indiana needed in 2024 is nothing like what Utah needed last December.

But 2026 has handed us a pile of evidence. Nearly one-fourth of FBS programs started this season with a new head coach, and the results are already sorting themselves out.

Here are the five profiles, in short.

1. The Lower-Rung Winner

He’s been a head coach, and he won somewhere nobody was supposed to win.

Curt Cignetti took Indiana, the program with the most losses in the sport, to a 16-0 national title in Year 2. Bob Chesney made the same jump from James Madison to UCLA, and the Bruins are 9-0.

2. The Heir Apparent

Some programs already have an identity. What they need is someone to protect it.

Utah didn’t run a national search when Kyle Whittingham left for Michigan. It promoted Morgan Scalley, who’d been on staff for 19 years, and the Utes are No. 2.

3. The Native Son With a Play Sheet

Kentucky hired a 36-year-old Louisville native who’d never been a head coach.

Will Stein has the Wildcats at 7-2 and No. 13.

4. The CEO

Revenue sharing turned the head coach into a CEO with a whistle.

Kirby Smart is the model. He went 117-21 in his first decade at Georgia, and the Bulldogs are No. 1 again.

5. The Big Name

This profile gets the biggest press conference and the shortest honeymoon.

LSU gave Lane Kiffin a deal reportedly worth $91 million. He’s 6-3 and 0-6 lifetime against Alabama. Virginia Tech hired James Franklin, and SMU just hung 51 points on his Hokies.

What the winners share

The coaches winning in 2026 have three things in common:

  • They’ve been the guy before.
  • They fit the place.
  • They can run the business.

A famous name isn’t on the list.

So what about Ohio State?

Ohio State wants the CEO who wins the big one. Ryan Day won the national title two seasons ago.

Now the Buckeyes have three regular-season losses for the first time in his eight seasons.

That’s pressure. It isn’t a prediction, and measuring it is what we do.

Want the full Diagnosis?

Coaches Hot Seat ranks all 138 FBS head coaches every week, from the hottest seat to the coolest. We measure pressure first, then the likelihood of a coaching change. We don’t promote firings.

This is the short version of this week’s Friday Diagnosis, our deep dive that goes only to newsletter subscribers. The full version breaks down every profile, the coaches winning and losing with each one, and what it all means for Ohio State.

Subscribe free:

The rankings arrive every Tuesday, and the Diagnosis lands every Friday.

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

Week 11 Coaches Hot Seat Rankings: Rutgers Keeps Greg Schiano, and Deion Sanders Takes No. 1

Plus 8 fired assistants, and every head coach who fired one still has a job.

Subscribers get an expanded version of the Coaches Hot Seat Rankings. Subscribe using the button below and we’ll email you the rankings each week PLUS you’ll get our Educational Email Course on how we rank coaches.

Greg Schiano was No. 1 on Monday. On Tuesday, Rutgers announced he’s coming back in 2027, and he dropped to No. 16.

Every week, Coaches Hot Seat ranks all 138 FBS head coaches by how much pressure they’re under, from the hottest seat to the coolest. We measure pressure. We don’t root for anybody to get fired.

Here’s the Top 10, and how each coach got there.

1. Deion Sanders, Colorado (3-6) | Last week: No. 4

Colorado needed 23 minutes to pick up a first down at Arizona State and lost 20-10. With Schiano out of the Top 10, Sanders takes over No. 1.

2. Sonny Dykes, TCU (4-5) | Last week: No. 2

TCU led Arizona 28-20 with under two minutes left. Then it fumbled a kickoff, threw an interception, and lost 29-28.

3. Tony Elliott, Virginia (4-5) | Last week: No. 3

Virginia had a bye, which beat its last three Saturdays. The Cavaliers have lost three straight, including 51-7 at Wake Forest.

4. Brent Venables, Oklahoma (5-4) | Last week: No. 5

Venables fired his offensive coordinator, gave the play sheet to Jason Witten, and won 23-7 at Florida. One win doesn’t wipe out four losses.

5. Matt Rhule, Nebraska (5-4) | Last week: No. 15

Illinois beat Nebraska 24-13 for the Huskers’ fourth straight loss. Rhule fired offensive coordinator Dana Holgorsen the next day.

6. Kyle Whittingham, Michigan (5-4) | Last week: No. 32

Michigan lost 15-6 at home to Michigan State, and Whittingham fired offensive coordinator Jason Beck. ESPN says Beck’s buyout of up to $10.1 million is believed to be the largest ever for a college assistant.

7. Dabo Swinney, Clemson (6-3) | Last week: No. 6

Clemson beat Syracuse 18-13, and its only touchdown came on a fumble return. A win is a win, and Swinney slides a spot.

8. Joe Moorhead, Akron (1-8) | Last week: No. 8

Akron led Ohio in the fourth quarter on Tuesday night, and Ohio needed 13 seconds to take it back. The Zips lost 28-20.

9. Tim Albin, Charlotte (1-8) | Last week: No. 13

Charlotte forced four turnovers at UAB and still lost 23-12. Four takeaways should buy you more than 12 points.

10. Lance Leipold, Kansas (3-6) | Last week: No. 9

Kansas led UCF with four seconds left and lost 33-32 on the final play. SI counts 12 fourth-quarter leads Kansas has blown over the last three seasons.

Just outside the Top 10

Lincoln Riley falls to No. 11 after a bye. Brent Key is No. 12 after firing four assistants in one day. Rutgers athletic director Keli Zinn says keeping Schiano isn’t “an indication that everything is fine.” Tosh Lupoi is No. 20, and his own general manager, Ron Rivera, told a radio audience Lupoi “has bumped his head a lot.”

See where all 138 coaches rank: coacheshotseat.com/#rank

Want the part we don’t post here?

Every Friday, newsletter subscribers get the Diagnosis, a deep dive on the pressure behind one of the biggest stories in college football. It’s only in the newsletter.

This Friday’s Diagnosis answers a question an Ohio State fan asked me on his way out of a loss: What’s the ideal profile for a college football coach?

Get it in your inbox: Subscribe to Coaches Hot Seat

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

Coaches Hot Seat Rankings – Week 10

Two offices opened up last week, and Greg Schiano got the corner one.

Sam Houston fired Phil Longo on Wednesday, and Florida State fired Mike Norvell on Sunday, the day after Clemson won 36-24 in Tallahassee. Last week, they were No. 3 and No. 1. Schiano lost to Michigan on Saturday, and around here, that’s how you get promoted.

Here are the Week 10 Coaches Hot Seat Rankings. Subscribe and we’ll send these straight to your inbox.

1. Greg Schiano, Rutgers (2-6)

Last week: No. 2 | Scorching

Rutgers had Michigan beat at halftime, and that’s the last time anybody in Piscataway smiled.

The Scarlet Knights led 13-7 at the break with a backup quarterback, AJ Surace, who finished 3 of 12. Michigan converted 12 of 16 third downs, which isn’t a defense so much as a suggestion. Tommy Carr ran it in from 9 yards with 4:19 left, Michigan won 28-21, and Rutgers is 2-6 and 1-4 in the Big Ten.

Schiano said he’s “very disappointed in the result, but not disappointed in the people,” which is lovely, and the people are 2-6.

2. Sonny Dykes, TCU (4-4)

Last week: No. 8 | Hot

Sonny Dykes beat Kansas and moved up six spots, so imagine what a loss would have done.

TCU trailed 13-0 at halftime in Fort Worth and punted seven times on its first eight possessions. Jaden Craig ran 17 yards for the go-ahead touchdown with 1:09 left, and the Horned Frogs escaped 22-16. Dykes revealed the secret: “We did it because we didn’t turn the ball over.”

Holding onto the football is now the entire philosophy at TCU, and it’s good for 4-4.

3. Tony Elliott, Virginia (4-5)

Last week: No. 10 | Hot

Virginia ran the ball 19 times at Wake Forest and gained 16 yards, and that was the good news.

Wake Forest led 20-0 at halftime and won 51-7 in Winston-Salem. That’s three straight losses, and the Cavaliers are 4-5 and 2-4 in the ACC. Elliott said his team “didn’t make as many of the competitive plays as we needed to.”

By my count, they made two: the touchdown and the extra point.

4. Deion Sanders, Colorado (3-5)

Last week: No. 5 | Hot

Deion Sanders snapped a five-game losing streak, and he should send Kansas State’s kicker a fruit basket.

Luis Rodriguez missed from 49 and 43 yards in regulation, and Colorado won 27-24 in overtime at Folsom Field on Isaac Wilson’s 11-yard touchdown pass to Charlie Williams on third-and-9. The Buffaloes ran for 222 yards. Sanders said Wilson “didn’t have to play hero ball,” which is easy when the other team’s kicker is playing for you.

Colorado is 3-5, and in Boulder that now passes for a turnaround.

5. Brent Venables, Oklahoma (4-4)

Last week: No. 15 | Hot

South Carolina scored 42 points in Norman, so Brent Venables fired his offensive coordinator.

Two days after the 42-25 home loss, Ben Arbuckle became the second offensive coordinator Venables has fired in the middle of a season, after Seth Littrell in 2024. Tight ends coach Jason Witten takes over the play calling. The Sooners rank next to last in the SEC in yards per game and touchdowns.

“We need a change,” Venables said, and he got one: a 10-spot jump, the biggest in the Top 10. Oklahoma is 4-4, and it plays at No. 25 Florida on Saturday.

6. Dabo Swinney, Clemson (5-3)

Last week: No. 6 | Hot

Dabo Swinney went into Tallahassee, won by 12, and then lectured Florida State’s fans on manners.

Clemson won 36-24, with Tait Reynolds running 79 yards for a touchdown and Nolan Hauser making all five field goals. Take away Reynolds’ run, and the Tigers averaged 1.9 yards per carry, so let’s not get carried away. Afterward, he scolded the fans behind the banner calling for Norvell’s firing: “Whoever did that, man, you ought to be ashamed of yourself.”

Florida State fired Norvell the next day, so somebody in the building agreed with the banner. Clemson is 5-3, and Swinney stays at No. 6.

7. Lincoln Riley, USC (7-2)

Last week: No. 4 | Hot

Lincoln Riley beat the No. 2 team in the country, and then he read the fans out of the celebration.

USC beat Ohio State 30-18 on Halloween night, and the fans stormed the field. Riley read a prepared statement afterward, and the win, he said, was “for all the staff members, the players, the leaders, admin, all the people within the walls.”

Then he walked away with one word: “Adios.”

The people who stormed his field live outside those walls, and he said goodbye to them in Spanish. He drops three spots to No. 7.

8. Joe Moorhead, Akron (1-7)

Last week: No. 9 | Warm

Joe Moorhead spent Saturday on a bye, and two firings did his climbing for him.

Akron is 1-7 and 0-4 in the MAC, and its last game ended with the Wagon Wheel staying in Kent after a 35-20 loss. Ohio is 6-2, and it comes to InfoCision Stadium on Tuesday night. That’s not what anybody would call a get-well game.

One win in eight tries, in year five, is a number that doesn’t need my help.

9. Lance Leipold, Kansas (3-5)

Last week: No. 18 | Warm

Lance Leipold had TCU down 13-0 at halftime and spent the second half giving it back.

Kansas took a 16-14 lead on a Martin Connington field goal, then let Jaden Craig run 17 yards for the winning touchdown with 1:09 left, and TCU won 22-16. Dylan Edwards carried 20 times for 42 yards, which works out to 2.1 a pop. The Jayhawks are 3-5 and 1-4 in the Big 12.

Leipold said Kansas can “play with a lot of people,” and playing with them was never the problem; beating TCU in the last 69 seconds was.

10. Bill O’Brien, Boston College (4-4)

Last week: No. 11 | Warm

Boston College’s offense went to Durham and never showed up, so the special teams scored the only two points.

Duke won 47-2, and Carter Davis got the Eagles on the scoreboard by returning an errant Duke extra point 100 yards. Nate Sheppard ran for five touchdowns, a Duke record, one week after beating Virginia with a halfback pass, so apparently he does everything. BC committed 15 penalties for 132 yards and is 4-4 and 2-3 in the ACC.

O’Brien summed it up in three words, “We got trounced,” and for once, a coach undersold it.

Bubbling Under

Bill Belichick finally found something he’d never done: score 35 and lose.

His teams were 103-0 when they put up 35 or more since he became a head coach in 1991, and No. 1 Miami beat North Carolina 38-35 in Chapel Hill on a late Malachi Toney touchdown. The Tar Heels are 4-4, and Belichick moves up one spot to No. 11. Brent Key climbs five spots to No. 12 after Pitt ran for 281 yards and won 34-11, and Georgia Tech is 2-6.

Washington at Nebraska was one game with two very different endings. Jedd Fisch won 17-10 in Lincoln and fell seven spots to No. 14. Matt Rhule lost it, said “I’m responsible for it,” and jumped 24 spots to No. 15.

Luke Fickell climbed 13 spots to No. 16 after the trip to Iowa City. He said Wisconsin was “completely manhandled for 60 minutes,” and Iowa has now outscored the Badgers 148-26 during five straight wins in the series.

Full Week 10 Coaches Hot Seat Rankings: coacheshotseat.com/#rank

Want to know how we rank all 138 coaches?

Everybody has an opinion about who’s on the hot seat. Most of those opinions come from a guy who watched one quarter and read one tweet. Ours come from the numbers, and we’ll walk you through how it works in a free five-day email course.

You’ll also get the free Coaches Hot Seat newsletter, with the rankings every Tuesday. The next time somebody tells you his coach is safe, you’ll know whether to believe him.

Take the free course

No related posts found.
VISIT OUR SHOP [COMING SOON]

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

Florida State Fires Mike Norvell 12 Hours After Losing to Clemson, Eats a $50 Million Buyout

Norvell won the ACC three years ago. Since then, he’s gone 10-22, and Florida State decided it couldn’t wait any longer.

Florida State fired Mike Norvell on Sunday.

Roughly 12 hours earlier, Clemson walked into Doak Campbell Stadium and won 36-24. That dropped the Seminoles to 3-5. Defensive coordinator Tony White and safeties coach Evan Cooper are out, too, and Rick Stockstill takes over as interim head coach.

Nobody in Tallahassee should be surprised.

The banner flew first.

Before kickoff Saturday, a plane circled the stadium pulling a “Fire Mike Norvell” banner.

Dabo Swinney defended him afterward. That’s a tough spot for a coach, when the guy who just beat you is the one sticking up for you. By Sunday afternoon, it didn’t matter.

The fans got there first. The school just made it official.

Remember 2023?

Florida State does, and that’s the problem.

Norvell went 13-1 that season, ran the table in the regular season, and won the ACC. The Seminoles won 19 straight games in that stretch, and Florida State rewarded him with a new contract. That contract is why he’s still getting paid.

Since the start of 2024, Norvell is 10-22.

The bill comes due.

Norvell’s buyout is 85% of what’s left on his deal, roughly $50 million.

That’s more than Maryland, NC State, and Baylor owe Mike Locksley, Dave Doeren, and Dave Aranda combined. Florida State fired its athletic director in September, so the Seminoles are paying for a coaching search without a permanent AD to run it. Somebody in the president’s office better be good at interviews.

Norvell finishes 41-39 in Tallahassee.

The resume, in short.

Here’s what Florida State got for the money:

  • An undefeated regular season and an ACC title in 2023
  • A loss to an FCS team, Jacksonville State, in 2021
  • A 2-10 season in 2024
  • A 3-5 start in 2026, with a plane circling overhead

One great year.

Six other ones.

What’s next?

Florida State’s job is now the fourth Power Four opening of the season, joining Maryland, NC State, and Baylor.

It’s a big job with a big budget and a fan base that just watched its school pay $50 million to start over. The next coach won’t get a 2023 to buy him time. He’ll get two years, maybe three, and a banner company on speed dial.

Norvell made it to November.

He didn’t make it past the first day.

Week 10 Coaches Hot Seat Rankings Drop Tuesday.

Whose next? Coaches Hot Seat ranks all 138 FBS head coaches every week . The rankings come out every Tuesday. Subscribe here and get them delivered straight to your inbox.

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

Week 9 Coaches Hot Seat Rankings: Mike Norvell Takes No. 1 Without Playing a Down

Mike Norvell’s Florida State team didn’t play on Saturday, and he’s sitting on the No. 1 hottest seat in the country.

In five days, Maryland fired Michael Locksley, NC State fired Dave Doeren, and Baylor fired Dave Aranda. All three were in last week’s Top 12. Norvell sat at home and watched the line in front of him get shorter.

Here’s the Top 10, and how each coach got there.

1. Mike Norvell, Florida State (3-4) | Last week: No. 4

Florida State had a bye, and Norvell climbed three spots anyway. His fan sentiment sits at minus-92, the lowest of any coach still working. Clemson comes to Tallahassee on Halloween night, so it’s No. 1 against No. 6.

2. Greg Schiano, Rutgers (2-5) | Last week: No. 2

Rutgers trailed No. 24 Northwestern 28-6 at halftime and lost 42-14. Last Friday, I said Schiano was next in line for No. 1, and he did everything he could to get there. Norvell beat him to it from his living room.

3. Phil Longo, Sam Houston (1-6) | Last week: No. 14

Two Wednesday night losses in eight days: 16-3 to Western Kentucky, then 30-24 to New Mexico State. Against the Aggies, the Bearkats ran for 11 yards. Longo is 3-16 at Sam Houston, and the man who fired him at Wisconsin dropped 21 spots this week.

4. Lincoln Riley, USC (6-2) | Last week: No. 11

Riley had two weeks to get ready for Wisconsin. No. 16 USC lost 24-7, ran for minus-17 yards, and scored the fewest points of any team Riley has ever coached. His review: “Didn’t coach good enough.” No argument here.

5. Deion Sanders, Colorado (2-5) | Last week: No. 9

Colorado led Oklahoma State 24-23 at halftime and lost 57-24. Isaac Wilson fumbled on the first play of the second half, and it got worse from there. Coach Prime keeps telling us the record doesn’t tell the story, and 57 points tells it just fine.

6. Dabo Swinney, Clemson (4-3) | Last week: No. 35

This was the biggest jump of the week, up 29 spots. Down 10-3 to Virginia Tech, Swinney said at halftime, “That’s 100% coaching. Pitiful.” Clemson lost 20-16 to James Franklin, whom Penn State fired a year ago this month.

7. Jedd Fisch, Washington (4-3) | Last week: No. 3

He had a bye week and dropped four spots, because the coaches around him did all the climbing. That’s the nicest thing that’s happened to him in October. He’s at Nebraska on Halloween.

8. Sonny Dykes, TCU (3-4) | Last week: No. 6

A week after beating Baylor, TCU lost 24-20 to West Virginia on homecoming. Jaden Craig turned it over three times, the last one a fumble with 34 seconds left. Nobody in Fort Worth is celebrating the two-spot drop.

9. Joe Moorhead, Akron (1-7) | Last week: No. 15

Akron committed 15 penalties for 165 yards and lost to Kent State 35-20. The Golden Flashes keep the Wagon Wheel for the second straight year. This is Moorhead’s fifth season.

10. Tony Elliott, Virginia (4-4) | Last week: No. 27

Virginia lost 19-16 to Duke on a halfback pass with 1:14 left. Before halftime, Elliott kicked a field goal because he didn’t want to do “anything too risky.” Duke didn’t share the concern.

Bubbling Under

Bill O’Brien scored 49 points at Georgia Tech and slipped to No. 11. Bill Belichick jumped 19 spots to No. 12 after North Carolina lost in overtime to Syracuse as an 8.5-point favorite. Shane Beamer beat Tennessee at the gun and fell six spots to No. 13.

Then there’s Luke Fickell, who beat No. 16 USC and dropped 21 spots to No. 29.

Friday’s Diagnosis: Michigan Bought the Wrong Résumé (For subscribers only)

Kyle Whittingham beat Michigan three times while he was at Utah.

That’s how Michigan got to know him, and it’s a big part of why Michigan hired him. What Michigan didn’t look at was everything else on the schedule. In 21 seasons, Whittingham went 7-15 against AP Top 10 teams, and at Utah he saw about one a year.

In the Big Ten, he gets them in bunches.

On Friday, subscribers get the full Diagnosis:

  • The number Michigan missed. His record against teams that are in the Big Ten now, and what happens to it when those teams are ranked.
  • The four-year slide. What his record against ranked teams looked like on his way out of Salt Lake City.
  • The comparison. Whittingham next to Kalen DeBoer and Steve Sarkisian, two coaches who changed jobs and had to beat better teams.
  • The verdict. Is Whittingham underperforming at Michigan, or did Michigan get exactly what it paid for?

Michigan’s administration bought the macro résumé and never checked the micro-schematic fit. Friday, we check it for them.

The Diagnosis goes to subscribers only, and it won’t be posted here. Every coaching change looks obvious in December. We show you why it’s obvious in September.

Subscribe before Friday morning:

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

Maryland Fires Mike Locksley After 13 Straight Power 4 Losses, and It’s Paying $9.94 Million to Do It

Eight years, one ceiling, and a 54-3 home loss to UCLA. Here’s why it ended, what it costs, who’s next, and who the Terps can’t afford to lose.

Maryland fired Mike Locksley on Wednesday.

It took eight seasons and a 54-3 home loss to UCLA to get here. Locksley leaves at 38-49 overall and 16-47 in Big Ten play. He lost his last 13 games against Power 4 opponents, which is the kind of streak that writes the press release for you.

The surprise is that he got an eighth season.

Here are the 4 things that matter now:

  • Why it ended
  • What it costs
  • Who’s next
  • Who has to stay

1. Why it ended: the same season, every season

Locksley could recruit.

Maryland produced five NFL draft picks in 2023 and six more in 2025. He kept Zion Elee, ESPN’s No. 2 overall recruit and a Baltimore kid, home in College Park. He grew up in D.C. and filled the roster with players most Maryland coaches only see on film.

He just couldn’t turn them into Big Ten wins.

Every year followed the same script. Maryland won its nonconference games in September, then the Big Ten schedule started. After back-to-back eight-win seasons in 2022 and 2023, Maryland has lost 20 of its last 22 conference games: 1-8 in 2024, 1-8 in 2025, and 0-4 this year.

Two years of that is a pattern, and patterns get coaches fired.

How do you survive 87 games at .437?

A UCLA fan on Reddit asked the question everybody else was thinking.

How does a coach last eight seasons while losing more than he wins? Part of the answer is where Locksley started: he took over after Maryland fired DJ Durkin in 2018, and the program needed a rebuild before it could worry about wins. Then came three straight winning seasons and three bowl wins from 2021 to 2023, and that bought him years.

The rest of the answer is recruiting.

Another commenter put it bluntly: Locksley got a long leash because he could land talent, even when he couldn’t win with it. Every time a blue-chip DMV kid signed, Maryland had a reason to believe next year would be different. His 2025 class alone had seven SC Next 300 prospects.

Eventually the losses come due, and on Wednesday they did.

2026 was the last chance, and everybody knew it

Last November, Maryland had the chance to move on and passed.

Athletic director Jim Smith brought Locksley back and promised more money for the roster. The Terps returned quarterback Malik Washington after a record-setting freshman season and kept veterans like linebacker Daniel Wingate. They opened 2-0 against Hampton and UConn, which is a sentence that should never make a Big Ten fan feel safe.

Then James Franklin brought Virginia Tech to College Park, picked up where he left off at Penn State, and Maryland hasn’t won since.

The losses kept coming: UCLA, Nebraska, Ohio State, and Rutgers.

The UCLA game ended 54-3, at home, a score usually reserved for September teams that get paid to show up. Earlier this week, Locksley acknowledged the frustration and said, “It won’t get fixed here at the podium.” He was right.

It got fixed in the AD’s office on Wednesday.

2. What it costs: $9.94 million for a coach who isn’t coaching

Maryland owes Locksley $9.94 million, about 65% of his remaining compensation.

Here’s the breakdown:

  • Lump sum: $4.97 million, due within 60 days
  • The rest: equal installments through 2028
  • Offset or mitigation: none

No mitigation means that if Locksley takes a coordinator job next year, Maryland still pays every dollar. The contract runs through 2028 because his 2022 extension added a year automatically every time he won seven games, and he did it in 2022 and 2023. The reward for those eight-win seasons turned out to be paying for the years that followed.

One more number: the buyout would have dropped to $8.9 million after this season.

Maryland just spent roughly $1 million for a head start on the search. Smith decided waiting until December would cost more than that. He’s probably right.

3. Who’s next: 5 names to know

This is Smith’s first major coaching search at Maryland, and his background is pro sports business, including time with the Atlanta Braves.

He has two jobs. He has to find a coach who can win in the Big Ten, and then give that coach the money to keep doing it. Maryland has never posted a winning record in Big Ten play and has finished with one or two league wins six times since joining in 2014.

Here’s who should be on his list:

  • Jake Dickert, Wake Forest: He’s won at Washington State and Wake Forest, two jobs that come with built-in disadvantages. Wake is 6-1 and ranked No. 17. The question is whether he sees Maryland as a step up or a step sideways.
  • Charles Huff, Memphis: He’s from Denton, Maryland, interned with the Terps in 2009, and worked under Franklin and Nick Saban. He’s 44-27 at Marshall, Southern Miss, and Memphis, with a league title at Marshall in 2024. The question is whether a fourth job in four years looks like ambition or a moving company.
  • Lance Taylor, Western Michigan: He won the MAC in 2025 and is 15-6 since the start of last season. He’s an offensive coach with deep NFL experience whose 2025 team still had the nation’s No. 9 scoring defense.
  • Dan Mullen, UNLV: He’s 117-68 in FBS with three 10-win seasons in the SEC and a strong quarterback track record. The 4-3 start at UNLV doesn’t help. Neither does the way Florida ended, especially on the recruiting trail.
  • Brian Hartline, South Florida: He’s 39, 5-2 in his first season as a head coach, and built the best receiver pipeline in the country at Ohio State. Smith and senior deputy AD Diana Sabau both spent time in Columbus. One season of head coaching is thin, but nobody would question his recruiting.

The name the internet wants: Brian Kelly

Reddit has already hired Brian Kelly, at least in spirit.

Within minutes, the jokes were up: Kelly studying how to eat a crab, Kelly watching The Wire for accent lessons, Kelly practicing Baltimore vowels in the mirror. This is the man who showed up in Baton Rouge and found a Southern accent somewhere between the airport and the podium. Nobody’s betting he couldn’t find a Baltimore one by signing day.

The funny part is that he’s available.

LSU fired Kelly midway through the 2025 season after a 5-3 start, and agreed to pay his full $54 million buyout as long as he made good-faith efforts to find work in coaching or media. He’s spending this season as a CBS Sports analyst and co-hosting a weekly SiriusXM show. He’s 64, and he’s said he hasn’t closed any doors on coaching, adding that his next job wouldn’t necessarily have to be with a national title contender.

Maryland is not a national title contender, so that box is checked.

At least one Maryland fan on Reddit said he’d take Kelly in a heartbeat if the school could afford him, arguing that a coach who could take the Terps bowling every year would be a massive upgrade. Kelly holds a 297-109-2 career record and won 113 games at Notre Dame. Maryland has won more than seven games three times since 2010.

The catch is motivation.

Kelly already has $54 million coming from LSU, and his buyout is built so that new earnings offset what LSU owes him. Money alone won’t move him, and neither will Maryland’s Big Ten history. He’d have to want the job, and Maryland would have to convince him it wants to win as badly as he does.

That’s the same problem Jim Smith has with every name on this list.

4. Who has to stay: the first recruiting class is already on campus

The new coach’s most important signing class is the one wearing Maryland jerseys right now.

Tampering season is coming, and a lot of these players grew up in Maryland. They’ll have to decide if they want to buy in to another staff and another rebuild. If they leave, the next coach starts over.

Here’s who matters most:

  • QB Malik Washington: He set the school freshman record with 2,963 passing yards last year. This season he has 1,615 yards and nine touchdowns, but also six interceptions, three of them returned for scores.
  • Edge Zion Elee: He’s the highest-rated recruit in program history and leads the team with 4.5 tackles for loss, despite playing only about 25 to 30 snaps a game. He also has 3.5 sacks and three forced fumbles.
  • Edge Sidney Stewart: He was a Freshman All-American last season with seven sacks, and he stayed when he could have left.
  • LB Daniel Wingate: He leads the team with 45 tackles, returned an interception 52 yards for a score against Ohio State, and has an extra year of eligibility if he wants it.
  • WR Chris Durr Jr.: The Wyoming transfer has 52 catches, tied with Ohio State’s Jeremiah Smith for the Big Ten lead.
  • Edge Zahir Mathis: He had six sacks as a freshman before a season-ending injury in fall camp.

The 2027 class matters too: receiver Myles McAfee, safety Kenaz Sullivan, and defensive end Dallas Pauldo are all committed, and all of them will be getting phone calls this week.

The bottom line

Maryland has gone 2-20 in the Big Ten since 2024, and on Wednesday it finally acted on it.

Locksley proved you can recruit the DMV. He never proved you can win the Big Ten with it, and neither has anyone else at Maryland. Now Smith has to find a coach who believes it’s possible and convince the people writing checks to believe it too.

Otherwise, the Terps just paid $9.94 million to start the same season over.

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

Week 5 Coaches Hot Seat Rankings

Saturday took down 8 ranked teams, and 5 of them lost in front of their own fans.

The top of the sport got shorter

Florida went first, and it didn’t bother being polite about it.

  • Florida 52, No. 4 Ole Miss 28. Jon Sumrall has spent 10 months calling Florida a sleeping giant, and I kept waiting for somebody to set an alarm. The Gators ran for 302 yards and jumped from No. 21 to No. 8 in Sunday’s poll. They’re 4-0 for the first time since 2019.
  • No. 17 Iowa 20, No. 18 Michigan 19. Iowa went 91 yards in 11 plays and won it on a Hank Brown touchdown pass with 2 seconds left. Michigan led 10-7 at the half and had won 47 straight games in that spot. It’s now 47 out of 48, and Michigan will tell you that’s still pretty good.
  • Wake Forest 30, No. 16 Louisville 27. A week after beating SMU, Louisville lost at home as a two-score favorite.
  • Mississippi State 31, No. 19 Missouri 24. Missouri was 3-0 when it got to Starkville and left with the same number of wins.
  • No. 10 LSU 35, No. 23 Texas A&M 6. A&M has lost 2 straight and scored 6 points in the second one. Mike Elko still has his contract extension, and TexAgs still has its message board.

Penn State and USC also lost at home, and both get their own treatment further down.

The No. 1 team can’t throw it

Texas beat Tennessee 20-17 in Knoxville, and it’s No. 1 in the country with an offense that ranks 111th in yards per play.

Arch Manning got sacked 6 times and was flagged twice for illegal forward passes. Afterward he said he didn’t play very well, but his team played great, and he got the first part right. Colin Simmons tied the school record with 5 sacks and celebrated one by pretending to urinate on the field. Steve Sarkisian looked into it and blamed Twitter.

The voters kept Texas at No. 1, so apparently yards are optional.

The poll let one 4-0 team in

Nobody ranked UCLA in August, and on Sunday the voters finally noticed the Bruins at No. 23.

It took a 54-3 win in College Park to get their attention. Bob Chesney is 4 games into the job, and his team scores 44.8 a game, 7th in the country. Pitt, Duke, Nebraska and UMass are 4-0 and still waiting in the parking lot, and UMass has a win over Rutgers to prove it wasn’t a typo. James Franklin got run off in State College last fall, and his Virginia Tech team is 4-0 and unranked with road wins at Maryland and Boston College. Both of those coaches are on our board, and Franklin didn’t help either one.

Franklin has become the guy who drops by to make other people’s seats warmer.

Georgia played somebody

Georgia came into the weekend carrying the softest schedule in America, and I was starting to wonder whether the Bulldogs would ever leave the house.

Then they finally played somebody and beat Oklahoma 41-13. Their defense allows 3.5 yards a play, the best in the country. Washington went the other way. Voters gave the Huskies 107 points in the previous poll, and Minnesota came to Seattle and beat them 27-24.

That’s the country, and now for the 10 coaches who spent Monday explaining themselves.

1. Michael Locksley, Maryland (2-2). Maryland lost 54-3 at home to UCLA, a team nobody bothered to rank in August, and the Baltimore Sun reported the customers chanting for Locksley’s job while the game was still going on. 247Sports and the Sun had both reported calls for a change before kickoff, so the scoreboard mostly served as supporting evidence. Afterward Locksley said he still has a lot of confidence in himself and his staff to fix it. That makes one of him. Next up is a trip to Nebraska, which is 4-0 and presumably looking forward to it.

2. Mike Norvell, Florida State (2-2). Florida State found an FCS team on the schedule and beat Central Arkansas 34-7, which is the kind of opponent you book when a win is the whole idea. The calls to fire Norvell kept coming anyway, per Yardbarker. That seems ungrateful. The man is 0-5 in one-score games since the start of 2025, and the Bears were kind enough to make sure this wasn’t one.

3. Shane Beamer, South Carolina (2-2). South Carolina lost 49-18 at Alabama, its seventh straight SEC loss going back to last season, and Yahoo Sports reported the critics had moved past the score to whether Beamer has control of his team. Dylan Stewart helped them make the case. The star pass-rusher punched Alabama tight end Josh Ford, then argued with his own coaches when they tried to get him off the field. On Sunday Beamer suspended him indefinitely and said, “There’s a standard of how we do things in our program.” One Gamecocks fan wrote that Beamer “grew a spine,” per Pro Football Network, which counts as a rave from a fan base that was chanting “Fire Beamer” after the Mississippi State loss a week earlier. It’s the right call, and a coach only has to make it once things have already gotten away from him.

4. Greg Schiano, Rutgers (1-3). Rutgers beat Howard 58-7 on Friday night for its first win of the season, and I’d like to be the first to congratulate the Scarlet Knights on going undefeated against the FCS. They are 0-3 against everybody else. The crowd was thin, and NJ.com was nice enough to blame the bad weather and the Friday kickoff. The 58 points would mean more if UMass, which beat Rutgers, had been the one giving them up.

5. Luke Fickell, Wisconsin (3-1). Luke Fickell finally won one that counts, and nobody saw it coming, possibly including Fickell. Wisconsin trailed Penn State 17-0 in State College and won 24-20 on a 72-yard touchdown pass from Colton Joseph to Jacob Harris with 1:13 left. It was the Badgers’ first road win over a ranked team since 2021 and their first win in State College since 2003, so it only took 23 years. That’s 3 straight since the 41-13 loss to Notre Dame. Nobody has to take this one on faith.

6. Dave Aranda, Baylor (3-1). Baylor beat Colorado 23-13 at home, and for once the head coach got the credit for the decisions. Baylor On SI praised him for trusting a 54-yard field goal and for using his punter to win field position. I can’t remember the last time anybody raved about Baylor’s punting plan. The only loss is 17-16 to Auburn. The best team Baylor has beaten is Colorado, and Colorado is 2-2.

7. Lincoln Riley, USC (4-1). Lincoln Riley jumped 13 spots on the board this week, and losing 41-27 at home to No. 20 Oregon was the least of it. Dante Moore was sliding at the end of a scramble in the second quarter when Desman Stephens slammed his head into the turf. Moore left in a neck brace and an ambulance, bound for Los Angeles General, with what sources told CBS Sports is a concussion. Stephens smiled and celebrated while Moore was being treated, which he admitted in his own written apology Sunday, and after his targeting ejection he spent the rest of the game back on the USC sideline. Asked about the celebration, Riley said, “I did not see it. No.” Asked why Stephens was still on the sideline, he said it was because “he’s on our football team.” The equipment manager is on the football team too. By Sunday the same conduct was “unacceptable” in a Riley statement, and the price was 1 game, Saturday against Washington. Dan Lanning called it a disgusting play and said you’d never see that from his players or his coaches. He also said it wasn’t necessarily an indictment of Riley, because he couldn’t speak to what he didn’t see. Shane Beamer didn’t see his own player’s punch in Tuscaloosa either. When he saw the video after the game, he told reporters Saturday night he was embarrassed, and on Sunday he suspended Dylan Stewart indefinitely, the best pass-rusher on his roster, with his future in the program still undecided. Stewart punched a tight end and has no return date. Stephens sent a quarterback to the hospital while smiling about it, and he misses 1 game. Both coaches missed it live, and only one of them called it unacceptable the night it happened.

8. Dave Doeren, NC State (2-2). A week after losing at Vanderbilt on a play designed to run out the clock, NC State beat App State 41-31, and in Raleigh that counts as progress. The Wolfpack led Vanderbilt with 6 seconds left, and the play meant to kill the clock ended with a fumble returned for a touchdown, per USA TODAY. The defense still gave up 31 to a Sun Belt team on Saturday, and the same USA TODAY story counts 8 Power Four wins for NC State since the start of 2024.

9. Phil Longo, Sam Houston (1-3). Phil Longo finally got a normal offseason. He went into 2026 with most of his staff back and a roster put together early enough to coach, per Yahoo Sports, after a year spent rebuilding and playing home games somewhere other than home. All that bought him on Saturday was a 49-14 loss at No. 11 Texas Tech, and he’s 1-3. Imagine the chaos version.

10. Joe Moorhead, Akron (1-3). UNLV came to Akron and won 38-10. Moorhead has gotten credit for taking Akron from 2-win seasons to 4 wins in 2024 and 5 in 2025, its best finish since 2017. That tells you how the rest of the decade went. After the Minnesota loss he blamed turnovers, drops, personal fouls and special-teams mistakes on inconsistent practice. UNLV scored 38.

Where Does Your Coach Rank?

Check out our complete FBS rankings [HERE]. If you like what you see, become a free subscriber and have our weekly Coaches Hot Seat rankings delivered straight to your inbox. Paid subscribers also get our Friday deep dive diagnosis on a single coach that week, and an email course showing you how we rank every coach. Plus insights that will have your friends ask: How did you know?

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

Arkansas Bought Ryan Silverfield’s Memphis Record, and the Ratings Underneath It Say the Razorbacks Downgraded

Ryan Silverfield stood at the microphones this week and said he was glad Arkansas football fans cared enough to be this angry.

He has coached two games. The Razorbacks lost 43-10 at Utah on Saturday night, down 29-3 at the half, and by Sunday afternoon Mike Irwin, one of the longest-serving reporters on the beat, was telling fans to call the chairman of the board of trustees about the athletic director. By Monday, upper-level seats for the Georgia game were listed at $35 on SeatGeek. The new coach thanked everyone for caring.

Nobody has told him the crowd is not there for him.

The man holding the bag

Hunter Yurachek has hired this coach multiple times, once in December and once again every time he opens his mouth.

In December, he stood beside his new hire and explained that Sam Pittman had not been given the resources to compete in the SEC, which is an athletic director announcing that the previous six years were his own doing and waiting for the room to admire his candor. He promised the new money would push Arkansas into the top half of the league. The Athletic’s estimate of 2026 roster spending puts Arkansas last in the SEC at $22 million to $25 million, against a league average of $33 million to $38 million. Football under Yurachek has gone 36-61 overall and 14-52 in conference play across eight seasons, and the Razorbacks are 1-10 at home against SEC teams since the start of 2023.

Hunter, when the fan base does the math better than the athletic department, the math isn’t what went wrong.

The coach has been doing a second job since the day he landed.

On his first radio show in August, Silverfield told Arkansas that most of his time goes into raising money. He was not complaining. He has said he would raise $100 million or pick up trash, whatever the job asks, and he means it, and at Memphis he pulled corporate money out of FedEx while everyone else in the American was passing a hat. Arkansas hired a head coach in December and put him on the road with a pledge card.

Then the team committed 8 penalties against an FCS opponent and got run out of Salt Lake City by 33 points.

The number the search never ran

A rating settles whether this hire was research or a rescue, and it takes two lines.

The Simple Rating System grades a team by scoring margin adjusted for the schedule it played, with 0 as average. Silverfield’s six Memphis teams averaged +2.84 against schedules rated 3.30 points below average. Pittman’s five full Arkansas teams averaged +5.38 against schedules rated 5.16 points above average. The 2-10 wreck that got Pittman fired still rated +2.18 while playing the 9th-hardest schedule in the country, which is to say the worst Arkansas team in a generation rated within a field goal of the Silverfield career average.

Arkansas fired the higher-rated coach and handed the lower-rated one a $33.5 million contract.

Figure 1. Season SRS for Memphis under Silverfield and Arkansas under Pittman, 2020 through 2025, with each season’s strength of schedule beneath. Arkansas 2025 includes the seven games coached by interim Bobby Petrino after Pittman’s firing. Source: Sports Reference season data,

The record, and the fine print

Silverfield’s Memphis record is 50-25. Read what is under it.

  • The league never saw Silverfield in December. Silverfield went 27-21 in American Athletic Conference play and never once reached the title game. Mike Norvell, the man whose office he took over, played in three straight title games from 2017 through 2019 on that same campus.
  • The ratings never caught the record. Memphis never finished higher than 39th nationally in SRS under Silverfield. The 11-2 team of 2024 finished 50th.
  • Even the American thought his schedule was soft. Memphis never played a schedule ranked better than 75th in the country during Silverfield’s tenure. In 2024, the year of the 11 wins, it ranked 117th.
  • The last team faded on the way out. The 2025 Tigers started 8-1 and lost each of their final three regular-season games, the last a 28-17 home loss to Navy. Arkansas hired him three days after that.

None of it is a scandal. It is a coach who won exactly what Memphis asks a coach to win, sold to an SEC school at SEC prices.

The streak that sold the hire

The selling point was four straight wins over big-time opponents, and ESPN had it in the opening lines of the announcement.

Here are the four. Iowa State in the 2023 Liberty Bowl, Florida State in 2024, West Virginia in the 2024 Frisco Bowl, Arkansas in September of 2025. Those teams finished 17-33 combined. Two of them went 2-10, and one of the 2-10 teams liked the beating enough to hire the man who administered it.

Arkansas lost to Ryan Silverfield by 1 point and bought him.

Figure 2. Every Memphis game against a big-conference opponent under Silverfield, 2020 through 2025, by final margin, with each opponent’s final record. The 4 wins in the streak came against teams that finished 17-33 combined. Source: Sports Reference game results, CHS Hot Seat Diagnosis workbook.

Now the good news

Let’s be fair to Silverfield. He’s earned at least that much.

His Memphis teams were penalized 43.5 yards a game, cleaner than Norvell’s teams and cleaner than Pittman’s. They gave the ball away less than either. They never had a losing season; they won every bowl game he coached as the permanent head coach, and they were blown out by 17 or more just four times in six years. The program also climbed from an SRS of -1.29 in his first full season to +6.29 in 2023 and a 29-9 record over his final three years.

That is a competent, disciplined football program, and in the SEC, it buys a coach about a season and a half.

The matrix, and what the colors say

Our analysis sets his Memphis tenure beside Norvell’s Memphis and Pittman’s Arkansas.

Norvell is the same-school baseline, in the same building and the same league. Pittman is the SEC bar Arkansas decided was beneath it. The shading grades Silverfield against Norvell alone, green where he beats the Memphis baseline and red where he trails, because folding an American schedule and an SEC schedule into one average would hide the only adjustment that matters here. Pittman’s column sits there so the SEC number stays in view.

Table 1. Tenure totals and per-game averages. Silverfield at Memphis 2020 through 2025, with the 2019 Cotton Bowl in his game-level records. Norvell at Memphis 2016 through 2019. Pittman at Arkansas 2020 through 2024 for season and per-game rows, with his 2-3 start in 2025 in the game-level records. Green and red compare Silverfield with Norvell, with defense, giveaways, penalties, and blowout losses flipped so lower is better.

I counted the colors twice. Silverfield trails Norvell on 24 rows, beats him on 10, and ties 2.

The red rows are the ones that get coaches hired and fired: overall record, conference record, record against ranked teams, home, road, weeks in the AP poll, title game trips, both SRS rows, scoring margin. The green rows are points allowed, rushing yards allowed, giveaways, penalty yards. Some of that green belongs to the era, since Norvell’s American scored more. The rest belongs to a staff that keeps its shoes tied.

Tidy is a virtue. It is not a résumé.

Two Saturdays, and the promise he broke first

Silverfield spent nine months promising Arkansas would be the best team in America at the things a team controls.

He meant it enough to sit down with the game-day parking staff. Then North Alabama, an FCS team, came to Fayetteville, and Arkansas committed 8 penalties for 74 yards, lost the turnover battle 3-1, and the coach called the first half one of the sloppiest halves of football he had been associated with. At Utah, KJ Jackson went 14 of 34 before he was pulled; the Utes broke up 13 passes playing man coverage, and Utah gained 7.1 yards per play. The parking, by all accounts, was excellent.

Set the Memphis averages beside the first two weeks of the promise.

  • Penalty yards. Memphis averaged 43.5 a game under him. Arkansas is at 65.0.
  • Giveaways. Memphis averaged 1.2 a game. Arkansas is at 2.0.
  • Yards per carry. Memphis ran for 4.5. Arkansas is at 2.7, including sacks.
  • Points. Memphis scored 34.1 a game. Arkansas is at 20.5, and 31 of its 41 points came against the FCS team.

Two games prove nothing about a season and everything about a slogan.

The roster is his, all of it

There is no inherited-mess defense available here, because the mess is mostly his own shopping.

He brought in nearly 80 new players, including 42 transfers, the most in the SEC by PFF’s count, after the 2025 roster lost starters at defensive tackle and offensive tackle to the portal. KJ Jackson, the only quarterback Arkansas returned, started last year’s finale against Missouri and threw for 441 yards in limited work. AJ Hill, a Memphis freshman who followed his coach west, finished the Utah game. PFF’s preseason preview built the backfield around Braylen Russell and Memphis transfer Sutton Smith, and that backfield is averaging 2.7 yards per carry.

Offensive Coordinator Tim Cramsey came from Memphis, where his offenses averaged 36.3 points a game over four seasons as coordinator, and he now runs an offense scoring 20.5.

Defense coordinator duties went to Ron Roberts, who spent two seasons at Florida, where his units finished 12th in the SEC in scoring both years, and who was dismissed at Baylor by Dave Aranda. Deron Wilson stayed on as co-defensive coordinator after coaching the Arkansas secondary through 2023 and 2024. Chad Lunsford, once the head coach at Georgia Southern, is the special teams coach. The unit Roberts inherited gave up 33.8 points a game in 2025.

Arkansas fixed the worst defense in the SEC by hiring a coordinator from the 12th-best one in the SEC.

What Arkansas already knew about Silverfield

An Arkansas insider who covers the Razorbacks says the anger did not start at Utah.

The vast majority of the fan base, he says, “didn’t want Silverfield hired at all” and wanted “any name but his.” The coach then said and did the right things for nine months, and if he overpromised on discipline, it was because he had a 2-10 culture to rip out and nothing else to sell. Arkansas was prepared to forgive a bad season. It was not prepared for a season worse than the low bar it had already set, which the insider says is why the whole thing went “up in flames super early.” He puts 75% of Silverfield’s first offseason on the fundraising trail and calls that a major red flag.

Ryan, when your own fan base grades the fundraising above the football, the football has to show up fast.

Two more scoreboards make it worse.

Auburn hired Alex Golesh away from South Florida on November 30, the same day Arkansas hired Silverfield, and Auburn is 2-0 after beating Baylor 17-16 in Atlanta. Silverfield beat Golesh all three times they met in the American, which sounds like a point in his favor until the ratings turn up: Golesh’s last South Florida team rated +10.67, more than double the +4.79 of Silverfield’s last Memphis team. Back in Memphis, Charles Huff is 2-1 with the program Silverfield left behind. When CHS raised those two names, the insider laughed and agreed it does not help.

Memphis coverage described its fans as relieved to see Silverfield go, Arkansas fans were sick about getting him, and both groups were reading the same numbers.

Patience for a first-year coach

The best argument for patience is the same Memphis chart that convicts him, read left to right.

His first three Memphis teams averaged an SRS of +0.50 and his last three averaged +5.19, which lands within 0.2 of Pittman’s five-year SEC average. The man builds slowly; his two worst ratings were his first two seasons, and he has now rebuilt a roster from scratch in nine months. Arkansas went 0-6 in games decided by 8 points or fewer last season while his Memphis teams went 19-15 in those games, so a coach who finishes close ones could pull back three wins the scoreboard already owed this program. Pittman’s better ratings, for that matter, produced a 32-34 record and a firing, which is a useful reminder that SRS pays nobody’s buyout.

The climb happened against schedules that never ranked better than 85th in the country, which means the flattering half of his career never left the American.

The season the schedule wrote

The remaining 10 games were drawn up by somebody with a grudge.

Georgia comes to Fayetteville on Saturday, then Tulsa. October ships Arkansas to Texas A&M and Vanderbilt around a home date with Tennessee, and Missouri arrives on Halloween. November has Auburn and Texas on the road with South Carolina at home in between, and LSU closes it out. The market never priced this team for a winning season, and after Utah it is pricing Saturday as a formality.

Tulsa at home and South Carolina at home are the two Saturdays where a Memphis-built team ought to look like the Memphis teams did.


The Market Read

The number that matters is 4.5, the preseason win total Covers listed on Arkansas, with the under at -200.

BetMGM hung it a full win lower at 3.5. Both were posted on the Memphis résumé before a snap, and both said the same thing: the market never believed the record would travel. North Alabama arrived as a 40.5-point underdog and lost by 17. Georgia opened -24.5 at FanDuel, with ESPN’s FPI giving the Bulldogs a 96% chance.

The public and the numbers are at odds. The public is still paying for 50-25. The market is paying for the ratings under it. The value window is the two home dates where discipline decides more than talent: Tulsa and South Carolina, because that is the only environment in which the Memphis profile has ever produced. The fade window is the SEC road stretch, where Arkansas went 7-16 away from home under Pittman and Silverfield’s own Memphis teams finished 14-15 on the road. The predictive tell is the penalty column, which is running 21.5 yards a game above his Memphis average and has to fall before anything else in this profile transfers.

The win total is not a forecast. It is the market’s grade on the hire, and it was posted before a snap of this season.


What would change this read?

Four things would move it, and a win over an overmatched team isn’t one of them.

  • Flags under 50 yards a game. Silverfield’s Memphis teams averaged 43.5. Arkansas is at 65.0, and that number coming down is the first evidence the strengths made the trip.
  • A win decided by 8 points or fewer. Arkansas went 0-6 in those last season. He went 19-15 in them at Memphis. A single close SEC win is worth more than a month of tune-ups.
  • An SEC win in Fayetteville. The program is 1-10 at home against the league since 2023, and five more chances are sitting on this schedule.
  • A run game that functions. Arkansas is averaging 2.7 yards per carry. A 4-yard average against an SEC front would say the Memphis offense can block this league.

Any two of those by the end of November and the Memphis record starts looking like the coach instead of the schedule.

Bottom line

The call is that the seat is hot, the coach is exactly what his ratings advertised, and the hottest chair in the building belongs to the athletic director.

Silverfield is a disciplined, organized program-builder whose teams graded as a good American Athletic Conference outfit and never once as anything larger. Arkansas looked at 50-25 and four straight wins over big-time opponents and never asked what the 17-33 behind the streak meant or what a schedule rated 8 points softer does to a record. The counter is that his Memphis climb took four years and that two games with a brand-new roster settle nothing, and that counter is strong enough to keep Utah from being the verdict. The call holds anyway, because the best three-year stretch of his career rated a shade below the coach Arkansas fired for going 32-34.

He will get his four years, or most of them, because firing him without cause costs 70% of what remains on a deal that runs through 2030 and still sits near $19 million after this season. That is the safest seat in Fayetteville, and everybody in the state knows it, which is why the noise has moved up a floor.

Grade the coach on the penalty column and the fourth quarter. Grade the athletic director on the two numbers nobody in his office ran before he made the offer and signed the contract.


Want to know how we rank the coaches every week?

Get the free Coaches Evaluation Scorecard, the same card we grade with. It comes with a 5-day email course that walks through how to use it, and you’ll get the weekly rankings in your inbox as they are published.

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

WEEK 3 – 2026 COACHES HOT SEAT RANKINGS

Ryan Day led by 20 points in the fourth quarter Saturday night and moved 56 spots up the Coaches Hot Seat Rankings by Sunday morning.

That’s the biggest one-week jump anybody has made this season, and it happened to a man who went into the weekend sitting 115th with a playoff bracket on his mind. Texas took the last 21 points in Austin and won 24-23. Day didn’t coach any worse in the fourth quarter than he had in the first 3. He lost, and this board only speaks one language.

Here’s the read on Week 3.

Of the 86 games played, the ones that moved this board were the ones against opponents capable of winning them. Nearly every coach who cooled off did it by beating somebody with no business on a big-time schedule, and nearly every coach who heated up did it by losing to somebody real. The week graded the calendar more than it graded the coaching.

What moved and why

  • Ryan Day went from 115th to 59th, and it cost him 1 quarter. Ohio State led 23-3 entering the fourth at Texas and lost 24-23, which knocks down the 2-year win column and the record-against-ranked-teams column inside the same 15 minutes. He’s still 59th, so nobody should confuse this with a hot seat. The point is that 56 spots were sitting there the whole time, waiting on 1 bad quarter.
  • Brent Venables climbed 18 spots to 17th on a 17-10 loss at Michigan. Oklahoma walked in ranked 11th and walked out ranked 24th, and the column that punished him is the one counting games against the AP Top 25. He wins 73 percent of his games in the 2-year window and 38 percent against ranked teams. That second number is the entire profile, and it didn’t get better in Ann Arbor.
  • P.J. Fleck moved 11 spots into the top 10 after Mississippi State came to Minneapolis and won 38-13. It’s year 10, the Gophers were outrushed 252 to 13, and Fleck’s Monday answer was penalties and communication. “The penalties absolutely killed us,” he said, and he added that what he loves about this team is their fight. Fight is what you discuss when the rushing number is 13.
  • Jeff Choate rose 41 spots to 68th because Nevada lost 20-7 at Montana State. Losing to an FCS opponent in September is the cleanest way to heat a seat in this system, and Choate found it on the road in Bozeman.
  • Joe Moorhead cooled 10 spots, from 9th to 19th, for beating Robert Morris 45-10. Akron hung 45 on a team that has no reason to be on the schedule and it counted as a win, because it was. That’s 10 spots of relief bought at wholesale.
  • Dabo Swinney fell 7 spots to 13th on a 22-7 win over Georgia Southern. Clemson scored 22 points at home a week after LSU beat them 51-10, and a September date against a Sun Belt team cooled him anyway.

The top of the board

Greg Schiano is the No. 1 hot seat in college football at 0-2, and he earned it the hard way.

Rutgers lost 37-21 at home to a UMass team that hadn’t won a game since October of 2024, as a favorite of nearly 30 points, and Schiano called the performance embarrassing. 8 days later, the Scarlet Knights went to Chestnut Hill and lost 28-21 to a Boston College team that had already been beaten by 19 at Cincinnati. That leaves him with 5 wins in his last 14 games and none in the 2 most winnable dates on his schedule. His composite sits at 96.4.

Mike Norvell is 2nd at 92.4, a gap of 4 points, and the way he got there tells you what kind of week this was.

Norvell didn’t play. Florida State was on a bye, and he still earned a spot because everyone near him got worse. Luke Fickell dropped from 1st to 3rd for beating Western Illinois 36-9. The top of this board rearranged itself over games the top of this board largely sat out.

Schiano has been in it; he’d like everyone to know. Asked about the UMass loss, he reached for Teddy Roosevelt and told the room, “I’ve been in it for 39 years.”

39 years, and 5 wins in the last 14.

Top 25 on the board

Click the button below to see the full ranking of all 138 FBS coaches.

The seat nobody is watching

Tim Albin sits 12th on this board, and I haven’t found his name on a national list all month.

Charlotte opened as a favorite by more than 20 points against The Citadel, an FCS program, and lost 43-41 in triple overtime at home. The 49ers gave up 268 rushing yards and 6 rushing touchdowns to a team that runs the option without apology. A week later, Ole Miss beat them 41-9 in Oxford. Albin’s record at Charlotte is 1-13.

That’s the number, and it’s the reason the board has him ahead of Swinney, ahead of Beamer, ahead of Venables. The only win came against Monmouth last September.

“My heart hurts for the staff and the fan base,” Albin said after The Citadel.

He won a conference championship at Ohio in 2024. He has won 1 game since he left Athens.

Looking ahead to next week

Saturday hands this board 2 games with a hot seat on both sidelines.

  • Akron at Minnesota, noon. Moorhead is 19th, and Fleck is 6th, and 1 of them leaves Minneapolis with a September win over an FBS opponent. If it’s Moorhead, the top 5 gets a new resident.
  • Eastern Michigan at Wisconsin, 12:30. Creighton is 18th, and Fickell is 3rd, and Camp Randall is supposed to make this one boring. A close fourth quarter here lands on the 3rd seat, not the 18th.
  • USC at Rutgers, 3:30 on CBS. Schiano gets the 12th-ranked Trojans at home with AJ Surace at quarterback, the same Surace who threw 3 touchdowns and 4 interceptions at Boston College. Nothing on this date is built to cool the No. 1 seat.
  • Florida State at Alabama, 3:30 on ABC. Norvell hasn’t won a road game since November of 2023, a streak that now runs 1,024 days, and the bye did nothing to shorten it. Tuscaloosa either ends that number or makes it the story of his season.
  • NC State at Vanderbilt, 12:45. Doeren is 5th, Vanderbilt won 10 games last year, and this is the first result of his season that carries real information.
  • Charlotte at App State, 6:00. Albin needs a win badly enough that a respectable loss won’t buy him anything.

Bottom line

A September win over a team with a losing record is worth exactly what you paid for it.

Want to win the debate every single time?

Get our free Coaches Evaluation Scorecard + our 5-day mini-course on how to use it like a pro. Plus, get our weekly coach rankings delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up below.

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES