Coaches Hot Seat Rankings – Week 14

Coaches Hot Seat Rankings—Week 14. Our full rankings are delayed due to technical difficulties. Our team is working on a solution, and we will release them as soon as possible.

In the meantime, the Top 20 appears on our site.

The coaching carousel has started spinning earlier than expected this year, with two notable moves reshaping the landscape just days before rivalry weekend. On Tuesday morning, North Carolina shocked the college football world by parting ways with Hall of Fame coach Mack Brown, ending his second stint in Chapel Hill after six seasons. The decision came just 24 hours after Brown had publicly stated his intention to return in 2025, marking an awkward end for the 73-year-old who led the Tar Heels to six straight bowl appearances during his return tenure.

While Brown prepares for his final game against NC State this Saturday, Rice made its move by hiring Davidson head coach Scott Abell to lead their program. Abell, who built Davidson into an FCS powerhouse with his innovative triple-option offense, faces the challenge of translating his success to the FBS level.

These early moves could be harbingers of a relatively quiet coaching carousel, as many programs appear hesitant to make changes amid uncertainty surrounding player revenue sharing and a thin candidate pool. However, that hasn’t stopped the temperature from rising for several coaches fighting to save their jobs.

In this week’s Hot Seat Rankings, we examine the mounting pressure at FIU, where Mike MacIntyre’s tenure has devolved into chaos amid allegations of misconduct and thrown furniture. We’ll also analyze Neal Brown’s expensive mediocrity at West Virginia, Kenni Burns’ historically bad run at Kent State, and the declining returns at Appalachian State under Shawn Clark.

Week 14 – Coaches Hot Seat Top 4

Mike MacIntryre, head coach of Florida International - Coaches Hot Seat

In the economics of college football, Mike MacIntyre’s tenure at FIU represents a perfect market failure – where moral hazard meets reputational collapse in real-time. His 11-24 record tells only part of the story; the real ledger is written in broken trust and thrown furniture.

The math is brutal: one chair was thrown in a rivalry game halftime, twelve current players silently support allegations of misconduct, and eight are starters. It’s a balance sheet of fear, where scholarships become leverage and silence becomes currency.

MacIntyre’s recent attempt to rewrite FIU’s history (“this program hasn’t had a good history since the beginning”) reads less like a gaffe and more like a desperate man’s attempt to hedge against his failure. However, markets have a way of finding true value, and in college football, truth emerges in empty seats and player testimonies.

The most telling metric isn’t his 3-8 record in 2024 but the text message circulating through his locker room, begging players to defend him to the athletic director. It’s the kind of desperate liquidity call that precedes institutional collapse, where a coach’s credibility becomes the ultimate distressed asset.

In the end, MacIntyre’s FIU tenure might be remembered not for the games lost but for the moment when the cost of silence exceeded the price of speaking out.

Neal Brown - Head Coach of West Virginia Mountaineers - Coaches Hot Seat

Neal Brown’s story at West Virginia reads like a cautionary tale of college football’s middle class. In an era when programs are expected to ascend or decline, Brown mastered the art of maintaining perfect mediocrity—a feat that paradoxically sealed his fate.

Every season followed a similar script: flashes of potential undermined by predictable setbacks. He’d win just enough to keep hope alive but never enough to compete. His 37-34 record tells the story of a program stuck in limbo, neither good enough to challenge the conference elite nor bad enough to force immediate change.

The numbers that matter aren’t the wins and losses but the empty seats at Milan Puskar Stadium. In college football’s attention economy, being average is worse than being terrible. At least terrible teams inspire passion. Brown’s teams inspired something far more dangerous: indifference.

The 2024 season, following a deceptively promising 9-4 campaign exposed the fundamental flaw in Brown’s tenure. When finally given a veteran team and heightened expectations, his program reverted to its mean. A pattern that speaks to a larger truth about college football: you can’t build a program on almost but not quite.

Brown’s buyout is $16.7 million if fired before Dec. 31, 2024. Reports suggest WVU donors may help fund this buyout, making his termination more financially feasible than previously thought. The high buyout was initially considered job security, but donor intervention changed that calculus.

Kenni Burns - Kent State Head Coach - Coaches Hot Seat

Kenni Burns’ tenure at Kent State has devolved from a cautionary tale into pure absurdity. His 2024 season reads like a dark comedy: losing to St. Francis (PA), a non-major program, before suffering historic beatdowns at Tennessee (71-0) and Penn State (56-0). His overall record now stands at 1-33, with zero wins in 2024.

The numbers tell a story of competitive collapse. Kent State hasn’t just lost – they’ve been outscored 486-160. In MAC play, where mid-majors are supposed to find their level, they’ve been outscored 282-99. The final indignity came in losing the Wagon Wheel rivalry to Akron, sacrificing even the $5,000 bonus that might have helped with those credit card payments.

But the contract extension through 2028 transforms this from tragedy into farce. Kent State isn’t just paying for failure – they’re financing it long-term, like a subprime mortgage on competitive irrelevance. Their head coach can’t balance his checkbook, and their football program can’t score a point against top-25 teams. Both, somehow, keep getting extended credit.

In the end, Burns isn’t just losing games—he’s redefining the boundaries of institutional patience in an industry famous for lacking it.

Burns’ buyout after 2024 is $1.51 million, per his contract extension signed in February 2024. This figure represents approximately three years of his base salary at Kent State.

Shawn Clark - Appalachian State Head Coach - Coaches Hot Seat

The 2024 season has only reinforced the narrative of App State’s decline under Clark. At 5-5 (potentially 5-6 with Georgia Southern remaining), the program continues its downward trajectory from its previous G5 powerhouse status.

Key 2024 Issues:

  • Blowout losses (66-20 to Clemson, 48-14 to South Alabama)
  • 2-5 in Sun Belt before recent recovery
  • Defensive collapse (allowing 35.1 PPG)

However, recent wins over JMU and ODU show signs of life. The question is whether this late-season surge can save Clark’s job, especially given his careful contract structure with decreasing buyouts.

The math is stark: Clark’s overall record is now 44-28 (.611), but the trend line points downward. For a program that once dominated the Sun Belt, mediocrity feels like failure. App State faces a decision: whether maintaining a winning record justifies retaining a coach who’s transformed their championship expectations into bowl eligibility hopes.

Post your comments here

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

Hot Seat Saturday: Where Every Snap Could Be a Coach’s Last

This is Hot Seat Saturday, and the gridiron isn’t just a battleground for players; it’s a high-stakes arena where coaches fight for their careers. Across the nation, embattled coaches face must-win situations, their every decision scrutinized under the intense pressure of the hot seat. From the SEC to the Big 12, programs are teetering on the brink of change, and this weekend could be the tipping point. Join us as we delve into the most compelling Hot Seat matchups, where a single play could make or break a coach’s destiny.

Auburn @ Missouri: Can Drinkwitz Turn Up the Heat on Freeze?

Time: Noon Easter/9:00 AM Pacific

Network: ESPN

The Tigers clash in Columbia this Saturday, but the real story lies on the sidelines. Eli Drinkwitz, with his Missouri Tigers at 5-1 and sniffing a playoff berth, has a chance to turn up the heat on Hugh Freeze and his struggling Auburn squad. Freeze, already on shaky ground at 2-4, can ill afford another loss, especially one against a team Auburn should, on paper, be competitive with. Missouri’s offense, while not flashy, has been efficient, and their defense will be looking to feast on Auburn’s turnover-prone quarterback, Payton Thorne. If Drinkwitz can orchestrate a convincing win, it could send Freeze further down the hot seat and solidify Drinkwitz’s status as a rising star in the SEC.

Tulsa @ Temple: Drayton’s Last Stand? Fry’s History Suggests So.

Game Time: 2:00 PM Eastern/11:00 AM Pacific

Network: ESPN+

This Saturday’s clash between Temple and Tulsa isn’t just a battle of two winless AAC teams; it’s a potential last stand for Owls head coach Stan Drayton, and the man in the stands, new university president John Fry, might be the one to seal his fate. With Temple sitting at a dismal 1-5, Drayton’s seat is scorching hot. A loss to a similarly struggling Tulsa team could be the final straw, especially considering Fry’s history.

While Fry has voiced support for Temple athletics, his 2016 op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, where he defended Drexel University’s decision not to have a football team, paints a different picture. This raises the stakes significantly for Drayton. He needs to convince Fry that football is worth investing in at Temple. Tulsa’s ground-heavy attack will test the Owls’ porous run defense, while Temple’s offense, led by receiver Dante Wright, must exploit a Tulsa defense that’s among the nation’s worst. For Drayton, this game is less about X’s and O’s and more about survival. A win could buy him some time and show Fry a glimmer of hope, but another loss might be another step toward the end of his tenure in Philadelphia. Fry, with his cost-conscious approach to athletics, might decide it’s time for a fresh start.

UAB @ USF: Dilfer’s Dumpster Fire Heads to Tampa, Is His Job Next?

Game Time: 3:30 Eastern/12:30 Pacific

Network: ESPN+

This Saturday’s matchup between UAB and USF features two teams desperate for a win, but the pressure is squarely on the shoulders of UAB head coach Trent Dilfer. Despite being favored by 13.5 points, USF enters the game at a disappointing 2-4, mirroring UAB’s own struggles. However, Dilfer, now in his second year at the helm, is already facing serious questions about his leadership and offensive approach, especially after last week’s demoralizing loss where the Blazers appeared to quit.

Dilfer’s Blazers have been a certifiable dumpster fire this season, ranking among the nation’s worst in scoring. Quarterback play has been inconsistent, and the run game hasn’t provided much relief. This all culminates in a program that looks like it’s lost its fight. Meanwhile, USF, despite their offensive woes, might have found a spark in backup quarterback Bryce Archie, who showed promise in their last outing. It might be the final straw if Dilfer can’t rally his Blazers to a convincing victory against a vulnerable USF squad. This game is a crucial test for Dilfer, which could determine whether he keeps his job at UAB.

Baylor @ Texas Tech: Can McGuire Deliver the Knockout Blow to Aranda?

Game Time: 4:00 PM Eastern/1:00 PM Pacific

Network: ESPN 2

This Saturday’s matchup between Texas Tech and Baylor is more than just a Big 12 showdown; it’s a potential turning point in the coaching careers of both Joey McGuire and Dave Aranda. With his Red Raiders at a surprising 5-1 and undefeated in conference play, McGuire can deliver a knockout blow to Aranda, who sits atop the Coaches Hot Seat Rankings. Aranda’s Bears, at a dismal 2-4 and winless in the Big 12, are reeling, and a loss to their in-state rivals could be the final straw.

Texas Tech’s offense, led by quarterback Behren Morton, has been efficient both through the air and on the ground. They’ll look to exploit a Baylor defense that struggles mightily on the road. For Aranda, this game is about more than just stopping the bleeding; it’s about proving he can still rally his team and compete in a tough conference. A loss, especially a decisive one, could seal his fate in Waco. McGuire, meanwhile, has a chance to solidify his status as a rising star in the Big 12 and potentially send his former colleague packing.

Kansas State @ West Virginia: “Are You Having Fun?” Brown’s Plea and Klieman’s Push for Big 12 Supremacy

Game Time: 7:30 PM Eastern/4:30 PM Pacific

Network: Fox

This Saturday’s clash between Kansas State and West Virginia is a tale of two coaches heading in opposite directions, fueled by a controversial question. Chris Klieman, with his Wildcats ranked #17 and fresh off a comeback victory, is looking to solidify his team as a contender in the Big 12. Meanwhile, Neal Brown finds himself fighting for his job in Morgantown, his fate hanging on more than wins and losses. Despite a respectable 3-3 record, Brown’s Mountaineers have faltered against every quality opponent they’ve faced, and fan frustration has reached a boiling point. This discontent erupted after West Virginia’s latest loss when Brown, in response to dwindling fan support, questioned whether fans were “having a good time” at games, a comment that sparked outrage and ignited a “Fire Neal Brown” movement, complete with a fundraiser to fund a banner being flown over the stadium.

This game is a crucial test for both coaches. Klieman must avoid a letdown against a West Virginia team that’s more dangerous than their record suggests. Their run-heavy offense, led by quarterback Garrett Greene, could pose problems for the Wildcats. But for Brown, this game is about more than just a win; it’s about saving his job. He needs to show progress and give fans a reason to believe, to prove that his program is more than just a “good time.” A loss, especially at home, could be the final straw for Brown, while a win might buy him a reprieve and a chance to quell the growing discontent. The stakes are high in Morgantown, and the outcome could significantly impact the trajectory of both programs.

Kentucky @ Florida: Napier Gambles on Lagway, Can the Freshman Save His Season?

Game Time: 7:45 PM Eastern/4:45 Pacific

Network: SEC Network

This Saturday’s clash between Kentucky and Florida isn’t just another SEC East rivalry game; it’s a defining moment for embattled Gators coach Billy Napier. With his team sitting at a mediocre 3-3, Napier is handing the reins to freshman quarterback DJ Lagway, which could either revitalize Florida’s season or be the final nail in Napier’s coffin.

Napier is betting on Lagway, hoping the young quarterback’s athleticism and playmaking ability can spark an offense that has sputtered under Graham Mertz. But throwing Lagway into the fire against a solid Kentucky defense is risky. If Lagway shines and leads the Gators to victory, it could buy Napier some much-needed breathing room and inject life into a stagnant program. However, if Lagway struggles and the Gators fall further behind in the SEC East race, the calls for Napier’s job will only grow louder. This game is a must-win for Napier, and he’s putting his faith in a freshman to deliver. The pressure is on in Gainesville, and the outcome could significantly impact the future of the Florida Gators.

No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES

Hot Seat Inferno: The Miami-Florida Showdown is a Must-Win for Both Coaches

Miami vs. Florida: The Hot Seat Bowl

Week 1 of college football is already shaping up to be a scorcher, and nowhere is the heat more intense than in the Sunshine State. The Miami Hurricanes and Florida Gators are set to collide in what can only be described as the “Hot Seat Bowl.”

Both Mario Cristobal and Billy Napier are feeling the pressure. Cristobal’s homecoming to Miami has been anything but triumphant, while Napier’s Gators are underperforming despite high expectations. A quick glance at their nearly identical records in key metrics paints a grim picture:

  • 0% winning vs rivals: Neither coach has secured a win against their biggest foes.
  • 22% late season wins: Both teams have struggled to finish strong, a sign of potential coaching issues.
  • Home field advantage?: While Florida boasts a 69.2% winning record at home, Miami’s is a paltry 50%.
  • Overall winning percentage: Cristobal’s 48% at Miami is slightly better than Napier’s 44% at Florida.

These numbers tell the story of two programs needing a turnaround. For both coaches, this Week 1 matchup is a must-win.

The stakes couldn’t be higher. A loss could accelerate calls for change, while a win might buy precious time and support. Every decision, every play call, will be scrutinized under the intense Florida sun.

Key Matchup: Miami’s RB Henry Parrish Jr. vs. Florida’s QB Graham Mertz. Parrish must carry the load for the Canes, while Mertz must prove he’s the answer for the Gators.

The Burning Question: In this high-stakes game of coaching survival, who will emerge victorious and cool their seat, if only for a week?

The Hot Seat Bowl is about more than just football; it’s about two coaches fighting for their jobs. The pressure is on, the heat is turned up, and the entire college football world will watch.

Georgia vs. Clemson: Reloading vs. Rebounding

Georgia, the defending champs, is looking to keep the dynasty rolling. On the other hand, Clemson is looking to remind everyone they’re still a force to be reckoned with.

Key Matchup: Georgia’s revamped defense vs. Clemson’s offense under coordinator Garrett Riley.

The Burning Question: Can Clemson’s offense keep pace with Georgia’s relentless defense?

LSU vs. USC: A Playoff Preview?

Brian Kelly’s LSU Tigers are rising, and Lincoln Riley’s USC Trojans are always in the spotlight. This clash of powerhouse programs could be a glimpse into the College Football Playoff picture.

Key Matchup: LSU’s QB Garrett Nussmeier vs. USC’s QB Miller Moss. Both quarterbacks are stepping into big shoes, and this game will be their first chance to shine.

The Burning Question: Can USC’s defense, which has been a major focus of offseason improvement, hold up against LSU’s explosive offense?

Notre Dame vs. Texas A&M: Tradition Meets High Expectations

Two storied programs collide in a game that could have profound playoff implications. Notre Dame seeks to build on recent success, while Texas A&M aims for a breakout season under Jimbo Fisher.

Key Matchup: Notre Dame’s new offensive coordinator Mike Denbrock vs. Texas A&M’s talented defense.

The Burning Question: Can Notre Dame’s offense find its rhythm against a tough Aggie defense?

Penn State vs. West Virginia: Upset Alert?

Penn State is a trendy pick to make the playoffs, but West Virginia hopes to crash the party.

Key Matchup: Penn State’s QB Drew Allar vs. West Virginia’s RB CJ Donaldson. Allar needs to lead the Nittany Lions to victory, while Donaldson has to carry the Mountaineers’ offense.

Key Matchup: Penn State’s QB Drew Allar vs. West Virginia’s RB CJ Donaldson. Allar needs to lead the Nittany Lions to victory, while Donaldson has to carry the Mountaineers’ offense.

Week 1 is just the beginning, but it could be the end for some coaches. Buckle up; it’s going to be a wild ride!


No related posts found.

LOAD MORE BLOG ARTICLES